On remand from the Ohio Supreme Court, the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals (BTA) applied the true object test to determine whether charges paid by Cincinnati Federal Savings & Loan (Cincinnati Federal) to Fiserv constituted taxable automatic data processing (ADP) and electric information services (EIS), or nontaxable professional services. The Ohio Supreme Court had previously
Sales and Use Tax
Tax me once, twice, but not thrice: Massachusetts ATB rejects double tax penalty on auto repair
The Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board (ATB) held that an auto body repair shop owed sales tax on the full receipts from its repair services because it failed to separately state nontaxable labor charges from taxable tangible personal property costs, notwithstanding that the shop itself paid sales tax when purchasing the tangible personal property incorporated into…
U.S. District Court swipes banking industry group’s effort to block Illinois’ law banning interchange fees on tax and tips
The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois ruled that the National Bank Act (NBA) does not preempt Illinois’ Interchange Fee Prohibition Act (IFPA), which prohibits credit card and debit card transaction processors from charging interchange fees on the portion of any card transaction that includes state and local taxes and gratuities.
In…
Indiana Tax Court: Cell phones qualify for telecom equipment exemption
The Indiana Tax Court addressed whether cell phones qualify for Indiana’s telecommunications equipment exemption from sales and use tax. New Cingular purchased certain cell phones that were later used to fulfill contractual obligations by either providing them free to customers who entered service agreements, or by issuing replacements under insurance programs. New Cingular sought a…
Washington DOR rules SaaS implementation services and travel costs subject to sales tax
In Det. No. 23-0004, 45 WTD 013 (2026), the Washington Department of Revenue (DOR) concluded that professional implementation services and associated travel reimbursements are subject to retail sales tax when provided exclusively in connection with a Digital Automated Service (DAS).
The taxpayer was a software provider that offered cloud-based solutions to state and local…
North Carolina Superior Court rejects DOR’s attempt to tax intercompany transfers lacking consideration
The North Carolina Superior Court held that intercompany transfers of product between affiliated entities do not constitute “sales” subject to sales tax when those transfers are not supported by bargained-for consideration, even if the taxpayer records the transfers using hypothetical “due to/due from” accounting entries.
The taxpayer, Asphalt Emulsion Industries, LLC (AEI), was a single-member…
Check your sources: Washington Appeals Court sources remote title insurance services to the location of the property
The Washington Court of Appeals held that a company’s title insurance and escrow services provided remotely should be sourced to Washington because the company’s customers made “first use” of the services in Washington. The trial court held that the services were sourced out-of-state to the remote location where the title company performed its services under…
Michigan Court of Appeals upholds indirect sales tax audit method
The Michigan Court of Appeals held that the Michigan Department of Treasury was permitted to engage in an indirect audit of a taxpayer because of its insufficient recordkeeping. The taxpayer operated oil change and automotive maintenance facilities in Michigan. It claimed sales tax exemptions for labor charges associated with its services. On audit, the Department…
Services or software license? NY Appellate Division determines transactions are taxable sales of software
The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, affirmed a decision of the Tax Appeals Tribunal, which determined that a company’s charges for a proprietary technological platform, referred to as a “vendor management system” (VMS), constituted licenses to use prewritten computer software that were subject to sales tax. The company matched clients with suppliers of contingent…
Mind the warehouse: California OTA says inventory storage alone can trigger “doing business”
The California Office of Tax Appeals held that storing inventory at a third-party warehouse constitutes “doing business” for income and franchise tax purposes.
The taxpayer was a Pennsylvania-based corporation making online sales of apparel through a third-party digital marketplace. The taxpayer also contracted with the marketplace to hold and ship inventory from warehouses (fulfillment centers)…



