On remand from the Maryland Court of Special Appeals, the Maryland Tax Court held that an unauthorized insurance company owned by Macy’s, was exempt from Maryland corporate income tax. During the years at issue, Leadville, a Vermont captive, did not earn any Maryland insurance or reinsurance premiums but had substantial interest income from intercompany loans with Macy’s. Under Maryland law, unauthorized insurance companies are subject to a premium receipt tax under title 4 instead of “all other state taxes.” The Maryland Comptroller argued that even if Leadville had paid Maryland premiums tax, it should be taxed on all its income as a financial institution because the insurance company exclusion for “all other state taxes” applied only to premiums related income, or alternatively, only to sales and use taxes. However, the Tax Court determined that it was commonplace for insurance companies to earn nonpremium related investment income and disagreed with the Comptroller, holding that the phrase “all or any” in tax statutes is meant to be broad and expansive rather than qualified or restrictive.
SALT Trivia: August 12, 2020
Calling all trivia fans! Don’t miss out on a chance to show off your SALT knowledge!
We will award prizes for the smartest (and fastest) participants.
This Week’s Question:
What state has the most reported False Claims Act qui tam cases?
E-mail your response to SALTonline@eversheds-sutherland.com.
The prize for the first response to today’s question is a $20 UBER Eats gift card.
Answers will be posted on Saturdays in our SALT Weekly Digest. Be sure to check back then!
The Final D.C. Budget: What’s In? What’s Out? What’s Next?
On July 28, 2020, the D.C. Council approved the Fiscal Year 2021 Budget Support Act of 2020 (“BSA”), which establishes the budget’s tax provision changes. The prior week, the D.C. Council approved the Fiscal Year 2021 Local Budget Act of 2020, which sets the budget’s expenditures. This year’s most notable event was the advertising service tax near miss. But the budget still contains numerous less-discussed tax changes, including amendments to personal property tax exemptions, the sales tax base, and the Qualified High Technology Company program incentives. And beyond this year’s budget, taxpayers should expect further changes later this year to account for the ongoing COVID-19-sized revenue gap.
What’s In the Budget?
This year’s substantial tax changes include:
- Greatly limiting Qualified High Technology Company incentives, including: (1) repealing the personal property tax exemption; (2) requiring QHTCs to have 10 (increased from 2) or more qualified employees in the District; and (3) repealing the reduced corporate franchise tax rate;
- Imposing sales tax on off-premises sales of spirituous or malt liquors, beers, and wine at the rate of 9%;
- Exempting from personal property tax certain computer software;
- For the unincorporated business franchise tax, including in “taxable income” “gain from the sale or other disposition of any assets, including tangible assets and intangible assets, including real property and interests in real property, in the District, even when such a sale or other disposition results in the termination of an unincorporated business”;
- Delaying the FAS 109 deduction until 2025;
- Imposing a tax and a local transportation surcharge on motor vehicle fuels sold or otherwise disposed of by an importer or by a user, or used for commercial purposes;
- Providing income tax benefits to taxpayers that invest in a Qualified Opportunity Fund (“QOF”), including the deferral of a capital gains tax payment for investing in a QOF, reduction of capital gains tax liability through a 10% step-up in basis, and abatement of capital gains tax on an investment of capital gains in a QOF;
- Abating real property tax for affordable housing in high-need affordable housing areas;
- For a decedent whose death occurs after December 31, 2020, reducing the amount of the unified credit for the estate tax to $1,545,800 (previously $2,185,800), increased annually, beginning with the year commencing on January 1, 2022, by the cost-of-living adjustment; and
- For a decedent whose death occurs after December 31, 2020, reducing the estate tax zero bracket amount to $4 million (previously $5.6 million), increased annually, beginning with the year commencing on January 1, 2022, by the cost-of-living adjustment.
What’s Out of the Budget?
On July 28th, the D.C. Council formally eliminated the advertising service and personal information sales tax proposal. Since this tax expansion became public on July 6th and voted on for the first time on July 7th, it faced massive scrutiny from the business community. Ultimately, the D.C. Council opposed the tax because of its deleterious impact on small, local newspapers.
What’s Next for the Budget?
The BSA will next be sent to the Mayor for approval or veto. It will then be sent to Congress for a 60-day period of passive review. But the D.C. Council expects to revisit the budget in a couple of months after it understands the full impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. It is an open question which tax changes the D.C. Council might propose at that time. Given the strong opposition to the advertising services tax, it is unlikely that it would resurface for so long as it impacts local media. But there is a risk that the D.C. Council would pursue personal income tax rate increases (which Councilmember Allen had proposed as an amendment to the BSA on July 7th).
The Eversheds Sutherland SALT Team will continue to track the District of Columbia’s tax changes this year, as the D.C. Council may soon need to choose between tax increases, budget cuts, or both.
California’s Flawed Proposal to Expand False Claims Act to Tax
In a forthcoming article in State Tax Notes, Eversheds Sutherland SALT partner Jeff Friedman and associate Dennis Jansen explore the issues with A.B. 2570 – California’s latest attempt to extend the state’s whistleblower statute to tax claims.
The bill is purportedly designed in increase revenues by targeting tax fraud. However, instead of exposing tax cheats, this proposal likely will primarily benefit a cottage industry of law firms that specialize in filing predatory shakedown lawsuits against unsuspecting businesses.
A.B. 2570, would amend the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to allow private parties to bring lawsuits on behalf of the state alleging tax violations, known as qui tam actions. These types of lawsuits are ripe for abuse because businesses will be coerced to settle or face the prospect of the CFCA’s financially devastating penalties and the legal costs associated with responding even to frivolous claims. A similar bill, A.B. 1270, failed last year after widespread opposition from California’s business community.
Lawmakers say that A.B. 2570 will increase tax collections, citing $470 million collected by New York after it extended its whistleblower statute to tax claims in 2010, and revenues generated by the IRS’s whistleblower program. However, for the reasons explored in this article, A.B. 2570 is unlikely to meet its lofty revenue projections. Similar measures in other states have failed to generate meaningful revenues while miring both businesses and the state in costly litigation.
Ohio Updates Sourcing Guidance for Marketplace Facilitators
Late last month, the Ohio Department of Taxation updated its existing sourcing bulletin to provide that marketplace facilitator sales into the state are sourced for sales and use tax purposes at the location where a consumer receives an order or service. The change allows marketplace facilitators to apply the same destination-based sourcing rules to both facilitated and non-facilitated sales (i.e., direct sales by the marketplace).
Tennessee Requires Marketplace Facilitators to Collect Occupancy Taxes
On July 22, the Tennessee Governor signed into law S.B. 1778, which requires short-term rental unit marketplace facilitators to collect and remit local occupancy tax. The bill, as amended, defines “short-term rental unit marketplace” to mean any person or entity that provides a platform for compensation, through which a third party offers to rent a short-term rental unit to an occupant. “Short-term” refers to rentals of less than thirty days. It does not affect hotels or bed and breakfasts. The changes go into effect January 1, 2021.
SALT Trivia: August 5, 2020
Calling all trivia fans! Don’t miss out on a chance to show off your SALT knowledge!
We will award prizes for the smartest (and fastest) participants.
This Week’s Question:
The Supreme Court recently determined that the eastern half of this state primarily consists of Native American reservations, which could have significant SALT implications.
E-mail your response to SALTonline@eversheds-sutherland.com.
The prize for the first response to today’s question is a $20 UBER Eats gift card.
Answers will be posted on Saturdays in our SALT Weekly Digest. Be sure to check back then!
SALT Scoreboard – Second Quarter 2020
This is the second edition of the Eversheds Sutherland SALT Scoreboard for 2020. Since 2016, we have tallied the results of significant taxpayer wins and losses and analyzed those results. This edition of the SALT Scoreboard includes a discussion of the Mississippi Supreme Court’s decision on agency deference, insights regarding the First Amendment’s application to Cincinnati’s billboard tax and a spotlight on New York cases.
View our Eversheds Sutherland SALT Scoreboard results from the second quarter of 2020 now!

SALT Pet of the Month: A Burrito with all the fixings!
Meet Burrito! This adorable pup belongs to Kelly Moriarty, Product Manager at Stripe. Almost eight years old, Burrito is a mixed-breed pup with all the fixings. Some of those ingredients include chicken, veggies, rice, black beans, guac, sour cream and salsa – or wait, maybe that was lunch…
But seriously, Burrito’s heritage is still unknown. A DNA test came back inconclusive, and the company had no answers for Kelly and Burrito. So Kelly likes to consider her a mix, between a German Shepherd, a Corgi, and a bat (she has GIANT ears!). 
It would be easy to assume that Burrito’s favorite type of food is Mexican, but that would be wrong. She loves all food, but her absolute favorite is Brazilian BBQ. Kelly’s partner is Brazilian, so Burrito often reaps the spoils when he grills!
In addition to eating, Burrito loves to play fetch, and no area is too small for her to run after a ball. She also enjoys doing tricks, and is great at “roll over,” and finding a ball or hidden toy that is out of sight using only her nose. 
Not only is she great at finding hidden objects, Burrito also excels at hiding items too. She loves to steal and bury Kelly’s socks around the house. She won’t tear any holes or destroy them, but Burrito loves to hide Kelly’s socks in the most random places. Maybe it’s her way of getting Kelly back for hiding her balls and toys.
Marketplace Laws: Implementing a Multistate Compliance Strategy
In this episode we discuss the top ten issues that should be considered when evaluating and implementing marketplace collection laws. It is excerpted from the third in our series of webcasts on marketplaces. In the prior two webcasts, we talked about marketplace collection legislative changes in the first one and the marketplace litigation cases and other developments in the second one.
Webcasts:
Listen to the hour-long version of this third episode in our webcast series here.
Episode One: “Behind the Eight Ball – A Look at the Past and Present State of Marketplace Laws”
Episode Two: “Stuck in the Middle Again: Latest Developments in Online Marketplace Litigation”
Listen Now:
Subscribe to our Podcast for more:






