Today the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held in Direct Marketing Ass’n v. Brohl that the Tax Injunction Act does not bar Direct Marketing Association’s federal lawsuit against Colorado’s sales tax reporting regime. The substantive challenge to the constitutionality of the reporting regime will continue at the Tenth Circuit. Continue reading
Noteworthy Cases
Washington State Maintains the Straight and Narrow Path: DOR Finalizes Interim Policy on Getty Images Case
By Evan Hamme and Madison Barnett
The Washington State Department of Revenue (DOR) issued an Excise Tax Advisory (ETA) making clear that Getty Images (Seattle), Inc. v. City of Seattle, 260 P.3d 926, 163 Wash. App. 590 (Wash. Ct. App. 2011), does not represent a major departure from established law in the context of…
South Carolina Court Changes the Channel on Cost of Performance Sourcing
By Charles Capouet and Timothy Gustafson
The South Carolina Administrative Law Court found that South Carolina does not source sales of services with a strict cost of performance method. The taxpayer, a broadcasting corporation, provides access to digital television entertainment via satellite dishes across the United States, including South Carolina. On audit, the South Carolina…
Virginia Supreme Court Holds That State Tax Commissioner’s Interpretation Prevails Over County Commissioner’s Interpretation in BPOL Case
By Charles Capouet and Andrew Appleby
The Virginia Supreme Court held that the Arlington County Commissioner must defer to the Virginia Tax Commissioner regarding the methodology for calculating a local Business, Professional, and Occupational Licenses tax (“BPOL”) deduction. Arlington County levies a BPOL tax based on the gross receipts attributed to activities conducted at an…
Financial Institution Cannot Assign Loans Based on Activities of Third Parties, Says Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
By Zachary Atkins & Prentiss Willson
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) refused to allow a taxpayer, a financial institution, to assign its loan portfolios based on the location of third-party loan servicing activities for purposes of calculating its financial institution excise tax property factor. The taxpayer earned flow-through interest income through its residual beneficial…
New York State ALJ Determines Travel Reservation Facilitation Receipts and Online Advertising Receipts Constitute Service Receipts That Must Be Sourced Where Performed For Income Tax Purposes
There has been significant controversy in New York regarding whether receipts from services—particularly those that may be delivered via the Internet—constitute “service” receipts or “other business receipts” for corporate franchise tax apportionment purposes. The distinction between “service” receipts and “other business receipts” is crucial because prior to 2015, New York Tax Law generally required sourcing…
Slow Down! Car Dealer Incentive Cash in the State of Washington Is Taxable Too
By Robert P. Merten III and Open Weaver Banks
The Washington Court of Appeals held that a Honda automobile dealership was subject to state business and occupation (B&O) tax on more than $1 million in “dealer cash” payments the dealership received over a four-year span from manufacturer American Honda as part of an incentive program.
Taxpayer Victories Are at a Premium: Alabama Court Holds that Business Privilege Tax “Premiums” Include Annuity Considerations
By Stephen Burroughs and Andrew Appleby
The Alabama Court of Civil Appeals ruled in favor of an out-of-state life insurance company regarding the calculation of its Alabama net worth tax – the Business Privilege Tax (BPT). The BPT requires an insurance company to calculate its Alabama net worth based on the ratio its Alabama premium…
Iowa Supreme Court Says VoIP Provider Is a Telephone Company
By Zack Atkins
Reversing a district court decision, the Iowa Supreme Court held that a cable company selling Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) service can be assessed centrally as a telephone company for property tax purposes. Historically cable property has been assessed at the local level in Iowa. The property of telephone companies—owners or…
The Jersey Short: New Jersey’s New Year’s Resolutions
Undoubtedly, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, the State Legislature, the Tax Court and the Division of Taxation have their own lists of resolutions for 2015.
However, in their article for State Tax Notes, Sutherland attorneys Leah Robinson and Open Weaver Banks suggest numerous New Year’s resolutions for New Jersey, including publishing an audit manual and…



