The Ohio Supreme Court unanimously affirmed a Board of Tax Appeals decision upholding the tax commissioner’s denial of a bank’s refund claims, holding that Ohio’s financial-institutions tax (FIT) is internally consistent and therefore does not discriminate against interstate commerce in violation of the dormant Commerce Clause. Ohio taxes banks through a regressive-rate structure, meaning that the more business a bank does in Ohio, the lower its effective tax rate.

The taxpayer, Dollar Bank, is a federal savings bank headquartered in Pittsburgh with roughly 70 branches, about 30 of which are in Ohio. Under the FIT, a bank multiplies its total equity capital by an apportionment factor—the percentage of its gross receipts attributable to Ohio—to arrive at its “total Ohio equity capital,” which is then taxed at three descending rates: 0.8% on the first $200 million, 0.4% on amounts between $200 million and $1.3 billion, and 0.25% above $1.3 billion. Dollar Bank sought refunds of between $461,732 and $640,158 for each of tax years 2016 through 2020, arguing that because it is forced to pay more than a similarly sized bank operating exclusively in Ohio, the FIT discriminates against interstate commerce.

The Court disagreed. Applying the internal-consistency test, it reasoned that the FIT taxes only the portion of a bank’s equity capital apportioned to Ohio, so if every state adopted the FIT, no dollar of equity capital would be taxed more than once—meaning no double taxation. The Court also found the FIT nondiscriminatory because an in-state or out-of-state bank with the same Ohio equity capital pays the same tax. It rejected Dollar Bank’s “aggregation” approach—that internal consistency asks whether a multistate business pays more in the aggregate than a purely in-state one—explaining that the U.S. Supreme Court has never adopted that approach and distinguishing Armco (which involved a discriminatory in-state exemption) and Wynne (which involved actual double taxation of the same income). Citing American Trucking Associations v. Michigan Public Service Commission, 545 U.S. 429, 431 (2005) the Court noted that the Supreme Court has upheld a tax yielding higher aggregate liability for interstate firms, and that accepting Dollar Bank’s argument would effectively forbid all regressive tax structures. The disparity, the Court concluded, resulted simply from Ohio’s policy choice to incentivize banks to do more business in the state, not from any discrimination against interstate commerce. The Court summarily rejected Dollar Bank’s Due Process Clause argument as a repackaged version of its rejected Commerce Clause challenge.

Dollar Bank, FSB v. Harris, 2026-Ohio-3069 (Ohio Aug. 13, 2026).